Skip to main content
SoleFeedSF
Buyer's Guide

Roa Neal Review & Sizing Guide

Published Updated

Buy Neal for a slightly more wearable ROA hiking-shaped boot than Andreas at the same price tier; never wear them on actual trails, expect the insoles to pop out on removal, and skip retail pricing in favor of waiting for the seasonal sale — full retail on a Made in China ROA pushes the value math hard I wouldn't buy them full price though.

Shop all

Key facts

Form
Italian mid-cut hiking-shaped boot, lighter and slimmer than Andreas.
Fit
Similar roomy ROA last; size down from sneaker size, closer to Doc Martens sizing.
Use case
Urban gorpcore styling, daily outfit boot; not a real hiking boot.
Build
Leather upper, Vibram outsole, contrast laces; Made in China at luxury pricing.
Value
Owners explicitly say they would not pay retail; wait for sale.
Watch-out
Insoles pop out on removal; same brand-wide QC concerns as Andreas.

Full breakdown

ROA Neal is the lighter, simpler sibling to ROA Andreas: same Italian hiking-boot DNA with a less aggressive upper, contrast lacing, and a slightly slimmer Vibram outsole. Owners who like Neal specifically call them sturdy and great-looking, but always with a caveat that they would not actually hike in them I have one pair of Neals and I'm happy with them, they're sturdy and look great, wouldn't use them for actual hiking. Buy them for urban gorpcore wear and outfit shape; insole-pop-out and full-price value remain ROA-wide concerns.

FAQ

How does ROA Neal compare to ROA Andreas?

Neal is the lighter, slightly more wearable sibling — same Italian hiking-boot DNA without the heavy Andreas upper. Owner feedback in the broader ROA thread treats Neal as a more livable daily boot, with the same fashion-first positioning I have one pair of Neals and I'm happy with them, they're sturdy and look great. Pick Andreas for maximum outfit weight and chunky lacing; pick Neal when you want the ROA look in a lighter package you will actually wear all day.

Are ROA Neal good for hiking?

No, treat them as a fashion boot. Even the most positive Neal owner in the gorpcore community immediately follows praise with "wouldn't use them for actual hiking though" wouldn't use them for actual hiking though, which matches the brand-wide gorpcore consensus that ROA is fashion-first. For real hiking, buy Salomon X Ultra 5 GTX, Merrell Moab 3, or La Sportiva; save Neal for the city and trails so easy you could walk them in sneakers.

What sizing should I buy in ROA Neal?

Hold the same sizing pattern as Andreas: most owners go down half-to-full size from their sneaker size, closer to their Doc Martens size. The ROA-wide sizing pattern in the gorpcore community is consistent I bought mine on sale, and even then, the price was way too premium for what you get with owners of multiple ROA models reporting the same roomy last. If you wear US10 sneakers and US9 Docs, try Neal in US9; if you hover between two sizes, go down.

Are ROA Neal worth the price, or should I wait for sale?

Wait for sale. The same Neal owner who likes their pair specifically said they would not buy at full price I wouldn't buy them full price though, and the broader ROA value pushback in the gorpcore community is consistent on this point. Pay 30%+ off at end-of-season; ROA discounts are reliable and the QC risk goes down when the financial loss does.

What QC issues should I watch for on ROA Neal?

Insole pop-out is the most-cited Neal-specific complaint, plus the general ROA pattern of sole separation and stained uppers that pushes the value math hard at retail price. The Neal owner who liked the boot noted exactly this insole annoyance the insoles pop out everytime I take my foot out when I'm taking them off, kinda annoying af. Inspect the welt and stitching on arrival; for the insole-pop-out issue, choose an aftermarket insole that fits the cup more snugly rather than putting up with the daily annoyance.