Skip to main content
SoleFeedSF
Buyer's Guide

Autry Medalist Review & Sizing Guide

Published Updated

Buy the Autry Medalist Low when you want a clean Italian leather tennis silhouette around $200-$250 and accept that comfort is polarizing on the padded tongue the most uncomfortable sneakers I've owned, especially for a $200 price point; skip it if you have ankle-sensitivity issues with unfinished sneaker collars, and wait for sale because Autry's seasonal discount cadence reliably drops the Medalist below $150 in select sizes.

Shop all

Key facts

Heritage
American tennis brand from 1982 (Wilson Sporting Goods), revived as Italian-made sneaker label in 2019.
Construction
Italian leather upper, padded tongue and collar, flat rubber outsole; winged logo on side panel.
Price
Retail $200-$250 USD; sale pricing reliably drops to $120-$150 across European boutiques.
Sizing
Runs true to size for most buyers; padded collar can feel snug at first.
Comfort split
Polarizing — some owners report tongue rubbing discomfort, others rate them above Jordan 1 lows.
Distribution
Heavy European boutique presence; Mr Porter, END., and US boutiques carry deeper sizing than mainstream retailers.

Full breakdown

Autry Medalist is the Italian-revived 1980s American tennis sneaker that quietly became one of the most-stocked European boutique sneakers of the last three years: a clean white leather low-top with a winged logo on the side panel, a flat rubber outsole, and a build that lands in the same Common Projects / Diadora B-Elite cross-shop conversation. Comfort opinion is genuinely split — one owner reports the unfinished padded tongue rubs the foot and calls them uncomfortable for $200 the most uncomfortable sneakers I've owned, especially for a $200 price point. The unfinished padded tongue rubs directly against my skin, while another Medalist owner says they are five times more comfortable than Jordan 1 lows I have 2 pairs of Medalists and they are 5 times more comfortable than J1 lows. Buy it for the clean Italian-revived tennis silhouette; skip it if you have padded-tongue sensitivity.

FAQ

Is the Autry Medalist Low comfortable enough for daily wear?

Comfort is genuinely polarizing — buy with the option to return if you can. One Medalist Low buyer documents the unfinished padded tongue rubbing against the foot to the point of unwearability at $200 retail the most uncomfortable sneakers I've owned, especially for a $200 price point. The unfinished padded tongue rubs directly against my skin, while a separate owner with two pairs calls them five times more comfortable than Jordan 1 lows I have 2 pairs of Medalists and they are 5 times more comfortable than J1 lows. Try a pair on with the socks you actually wear before paying retail; the comfort split is real and not about size.

How does the Autry Medalist fit, and what size should I order?

The Medalist Low runs true to size with a medium-width tennis last; the padded collar feels snug for the first few wears and softens within a week. Order your standard sneaker size for most buyers; wide-foot wearers should consider sizing up a half size because the padded tongue does not relieve forefoot pressure. The single buyer-experience comment on the recent Medalist comfort thread came from a fresh buyer who had not received their pair yet and was specifically asking about leather smell as a quality signal since they are supposed to be made of leather, do they have the typical leather smell or no smell at all.

Is the Medalist worth the $200-$250 retail price?

It is worth it at sale price of $120-$150; at full retail the value math gets tighter against Common Projects on the high side or Adidas Stan Smith on the low side. The Medalist gets named regularly as a Common Projects alternative in best-dress-sneaker threads, with the Italian leather and clean white silhouette as the value pitch a clean white minimal sneaker that you keep clean like Common Projects Achilles, Veja Campo or something similar. Wait for the European boutique seasonal sale; pay retail only when a specific colorway and size lock in together.

What is the Autry Medalist Low vs Medalist Mid difference, and which should I buy?

The Medalist Low is the cleaner everyday silhouette and the model that sits in the Common Projects cross-shop conversation, where it pulls votes against minimalist white sneakers in the same band a clean white minimal sneaker that you keep clean like Common Projects Achilles, Veja Campo or something similar. The Medalist Mid adds an ankle wrap that puts it in a more casual outfit slot. Pick the Low for daily wear with denim, chinos, and tailored trousers; pick the Mid when you want a slightly more retro-basketball look that still works with smart-casual outfits.

Where should I buy the Autry Medalist outside Italy?

Buy from Autry's own retail, END., Mr Porter, Saks, and select US boutiques; mainstream US sneaker retailers carry only base colorways. The brand is genuinely heavily distributed in European boutiques but thin in the US until 2024-2025 when SSENSE, Nordstrom, and a few smaller stockists added them. Wait for the seasonal sale cycle; the Medalist hits 30-40% off at most European stockists at least once per season, and the resale market in the US is thin enough that fresh US buyers verifying basic leather quality on arrival is still a normal Reddit question do they have the typical leather smell or no smell at all.