Skip to main content
SoleFeedSF
Buyer's Guide

Nike Air Penny 2 Review & Sizing Guide

Published Updated

The Nike Air Penny 2 is the sculpted 1996 Penny Hardaway signature, a solid retro buy for 90s-hoops fans who can live with its bulk and a short break-in.

Shop all

Key facts

Popularity
Steady nostalgic demand; niche next to top retro staples.
Comfort
Structured supportive ride; short break-in before it settles.
Fit
Generally true to size; do not size down.
Value
Retail feels steep; turns up discounted at outlets often.
Use case
Casual 90s-styled outfits, nostalgia, and collecting.

Full breakdown

Nike released the Air Penny 2 in 1996 as Penny Hardaway's second signature shoe, designed to feel more futuristic than the leather basketball shoes of the time with a sculpted midsole and visible Max Air. It sits between the first Air Penny and the Foamposite line in his Orlando-era run. Today it draws nostalgic buyers who want a bold 90s hoops silhouette for casual wear and collecting.

FAQ

Does the Nike Air Penny 2 fit true to size?

Most owners find the Air Penny 2 true to size and advise against sizing down, even if you usually go down a half size in Air Force 1s. Going smaller leaves the fit too snug given the padded upper. If you are between sizes, stay true to size or go up rather than down, as one owner specifically warned not to drop a half size unless you like a snug fit.

Is the Nike Air Penny 2 comfortable?

It is comfortable enough for casual wear once broken in, with Max Air cushioning and a padded interior, but it is a heavy, structured 90s basketball shoe rather than an all-day walker. New pairs can feel stiff or uneven at first. One buyer noted the discomfort eased after the shoes took a while to break in, and an insole swap can help.

How is the Air Penny 2 different from the Air Max Penny 1?

Choose the Air Penny 2 for the more sculpted, layered 1996 silhouette with a wrapping side panel and visible heel Air; the Air Max Penny 1 reads cleaner and more immediately recognizable. The 2 looks bolder but also bulkier on foot. Owners in rotation posts call it an underrated and still-loved retro, so the pick comes down to whether you want the busier design.

Should you pay retail for the Nike Air Penny 2?

Pay retail only if a colorway has real personal Penny value, since this is a niche retro that frequently turns up discounted. Buyers regularly report finding pairs at outlets like Ross and Marshalls in the $50-65 range, well under retail. At those prices the Max Air build and bold shape are a much easier casual buy, as one shopper found a real pair for $64 at Ross.

Who should skip the Nike Air Penny 2?

Skip it if you want a light daily sneaker, simple leather court styling, or zero break-in, because the bulk and stiffness that fans love can feel dated next to modern lifestyle shoes. Wide-foot buyers should try before committing given the structured fit. The weight is the main tradeoff, and even devoted owners note the netting yellows while the shoe stays a favorite.